Subscribe to the BioNews newsletter for free

Advanced Search

Search for
21 years of the Progress Educational Trust (PET), informing debate on assisted conception and genetics

Print Page Follow BioNews on Twitter BioNews RSS feed

Like the Progress Educational Trust on Facebook





EVENTS

Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?

Progress Educational Trust
Main Lecture Theatre, Royal Society of Medicine, 1 Wimpole Street, London W1G 0AE
20 October 2010

The Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
See photographs of this event below


An evening debate organised by the Progress Educational Trust (PET) in partnership with the Royal Society of Medicine, supported by the British Fertility Society and the National Gamete Donation Trust.

Recent headlines have reignited the debate over whether payment might be an acceptable way to address the current shortage of egg donors. Some newspapers have speculated that the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) is planning to allow women to be paid thousands of pounds to donate their eggs. Could such a scenario lead to British students 'going to university on an egg'? The HFEA will explore the possibility of paying egg donors in a public consultation beginning in January 2011.

After its last review of this question in 2005, the HFEA concluded that paying donors was neither possible (because it would conflict with the European Union's 2004 Tissues and Cells Directive) nor desirable (because 'offering compensation for the physical inconvenience or risk of donation may encourage some people to donate without thinking sufficiently about the consequences'). But in 2009, the HFEA's chair Lisa Jardine told the Times newspaper that payment to donors was worth considering if it could help dissuade fertility patients from seeking unlicensed or overseas treatment: 'My agenda is to try to keep assisted reproduction within our regulated area, not because I'm bossy but out of concern for patient welfare.'

It is already the case that egg donors receive 'loss of earnings' compensation, but this is limited to a daily maximum of £61.28 and an overall maximum of £250, which compares poorly with the £97.80 median daily pay received by full-time employees in the UK. It is also the case that egg sharing schemes are permitted in the UK, and these enable women to receive fertility treatment at vastly reduced cost if they donate eggs for use by other patients or for research. Some argue that there is little moral or practical difference between these nominally indirect forms of compensation, and direct payment. Others fear that direct payment would commodify not only eggs, but also egg donors and donor-conceived children.

This evening debate will see the issue of paying egg donors debated by a panel of experts with contrasting perspectives, who will explore the medical, ethical and legal dimensions of various forms of compensation and remuneration. In the PET tradition, following introductory presentations the bulk of the debate's running time will be devoted to soliciting questions and comments from the audience.





Sarah Norcross speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

At podium: Sarah Norcross
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Dr Sue Avery, Professor Brenda Almond, Professor Brian Lieberman, Professor Raanan Gillon, Laura Witjens and Anthony Rutherford speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

Left to right: Dr Sue Avery, Professor Brenda Almond, Professor Brian Lieberman, Professor Raanan Gillon, Laura Witjens, (at podium) Anthony Rutherford
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Dr Sue Avery, Professor Brenda Almond, Professor Brian Lieberman, Professor Raanan Gillon, Laura Witjens and Anthony Rutherford speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

Left to right: Dr Sue Avery, Professor Brenda Almond, Professor Brian Lieberman, Professor Raanan Gillon, Laura Witjens, (at podium) Anthony Rutherford
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Professor Brian Lieberman, Professor Raanan Gillon, Laura Witjens and Anthony Rutherford speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

Left to right: Professor Brian Lieberman, Professor Raanan Gillon, Laura Witjens, (at podium) Anthony Rutherford
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Dr Sue Avery, Professor Brenda Almond, Professor Brian Lieberman, Professor Raanan Gillon and Laura Witjens speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

Left to right: Dr Sue Avery, Professor Brenda Almond, Professor Brian Lieberman, Professor Raanan Gillon, Laura Witjens
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Dr Sue Avery, Professor Brenda Almond, Professor Raanan Gillon, Professor Brian Lieberman and Laura Witjens speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

Left to right: Dr Sue Avery, Professor Brenda Almond, Professor Raanan Gillon, Professor Brian Lieberman, Laura Witjens
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Anthony Rutherford, Dr Sue Avery and Professor Brenda Almond speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

Left to right: Anthony Rutherford, Dr Sue Avery, Professor Brenda Almond
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Professor Raanan Gillon and Laura Witjens speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

Left to right: Professor Raanan Gillon, Laura Witjens
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Professor Brian Lieberman, Laura Witjens and Professor Raanan Gillon speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

Left to right: Professor Brian Lieberman, Laura Witjens, (at podium) Professor Raanan Gillon
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Anthony Rutherford speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

At podium: Anthony Rutherford
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Professor Brenda Almond speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

At podium: Professor Brenda Almond
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Dr Sue Avery speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

At podium: Dr Sue Avery
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Professor Brian Lieberman speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

At podium: Professor Brian Lieberman
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Professor Raanan Gillon speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

At podium: Professor Raanan Gillon
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Laura Witjens speaking at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

At podium: Laura Witjens
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


Sandy Starr, Rebecca Jenkins, Zoe Oppong and Kerry Dyus at the Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

Left to right at registration: Sandy Starr, Rebecca Jenkins, Zoe Oppong, Kerry Dyus
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda


The Progress Educational Trust event 'Paying Egg Donors: A Child At Any Price?' (photograph by Lahiru Dayananda)

Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda

PET CONFERENCE
COMMERCIALISATION OF LIFE


'The Commercialisation of Life', Progress Educational Trust conference, central London, Tuesday 2 December 2014 - book HERE

London, 2 December
Click HERE for details

Datalabel The UK's Leading Supplier Of Medical Labels & Asset Labels

Become a Friend of PET HERE and give the Progress Educational Trust a regular donation

Good Fundraising Code

Find out more about the Progress Educational Trust by downloading our brochure HERE

Advertising & sponsorship
Terms & conditions
Sitemap

Progress Educational Trust, 140 Grays Inn Road, London WC1X 8AX, UK
Tel: +44 (0)20 7278 7870 Email:
Limited company registered in England and Wales no 07405980
Registered charity no 1139856

Website developed and built by Face to Face
Website designed by Thunder
Website administration

© 1992, 2013
Progress Educational Trust