Photograph by Sarah Norcross
See photographs of this event below
An evening debate organised by the Progress Educational Trust (PET) in partnership with University College London's Genetics Institute, and supported by the Wellcome Trust. This event marked the launch of the PET project Genes, Ancestry and Racial Identity: Does It Matter Where Your Genes Come From? (which continued with the succeeding events Will Pharmacogenetics Lead to Colour-Coded Medicine? and Genetic Medalling).
The relationship between genes, race, ethnicity and identity is one of the most contested and controversial fields of academic inquiry. Historically, it was believed that people were divisible into racial types as a result of human biological variation. In the twentieth century, figures such as Richard Lewontin argued persuasively that this was not the case, and that race was in fact a socially constructed phenomenon.
Unsurprisingly, debate about the meaning of race has been refuelled by recent genetic advances and genome-wide association studies, and persists in both the popular and the scientific press. Whereas race has traditionally been defined either by skin colour and facial features or by geography, it is now becoming possible to search for the meaning of race at the molecular level. For example, it has been claimed that Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry can be traced back three centuries, to one woman.
There has also been a recent surge of interest in the proposition that 'mixed race is better'. In its most popular form, this proposition depends upon a highly questionable application of the biological concept of 'hybrid vigour' to humans. More subtle versions of this idea examine the psychological factors that might lead us to perceive people of mixed race as attractive.
This public event will see experts with contrasting perspectives debate what, if anything, the word 'race' can offer us. Are there contexts, in biology or more broadly, in which the term is legitimate and useful? Or should we be seeking to put it behind us?
In the PET tradition, following introductory presentations the bulk of the debate's running time will be devoted to soliciting questions and comments from the audience.
-
Dr Neil Bradman
Chair of University College London's Centre for Genetic Anthropology, and Associate Member of the Ancient DNA Research Group at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem -
Dr Aarathi Prasad
Science writer and broadcaster, and presenter of the TV programme Is It Better to Be Mixed Race? -
Dr Jim Wilson
Managing Director and Founder of EthnoAncestry, and Royal Society Research Fellow at the University of Edinburgh's Centre for Population Health Sciences
Speakers
-
Professor Marcus Pembrey
Founding Chair of Trustees at PET and Emeritus Professor of Paediatric Genetics at University College London's Institute of Child Health
Chair
Partners and supporters
At lectern: Sarah Norcross
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Left to right on speaker panel: Dr Neil Bradman, Dr Jim Wilson, Dr Aarathi Prasad, Professor Marcus Pembrey
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Left to right: Dr Neil Bradman, Dr Jim Wilson, Dr Aarathi Prasad, (at lectern) Professor Marcus Pembrey
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Left to right in background: Dr Neil Bradman, Dr Jim Wilson, Dr Aarathi Prasad, Professor Marcus Pembrey
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Left to right on speaker panel: Dr Neil Bradman, Dr Jim Wilson, Dr Aarathi Prasad
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Left to right on speaker panel: Dr Neil Bradman, Dr Jim Wilson, Dr Aarathi Prasad
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Left to right on speaker panel: Dr Neil Bradman, Dr Jim Wilson, Dr Aarathi Prasad
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Left to right: Dr Neil Bradman, Dr Jim Wilson
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Left to right: Dr Jim Wilson, Dr Aarathi Prasad
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
At lectern: Professor Marcus Pembrey
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
At lectern: Professor Marcus Pembrey
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Dr Neil Bradman
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Dr Neil Bradman
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
At lectern: Dr Aarathi Prasad
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Dr Aarathi Prasad
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Dr Jim Wilson
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
At lectern: Dr Jim Wilson
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Dr Jim Wilson
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Standing: Sandy Starr
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
Left to right at registration: Kerry Dyus, Sandy Starr, Professor Marcus Pembrey
Photograph by Lahiru Dayananda
At registration: Progress Educational Trust display stand
