I imagine that for a couple trying to create a family together, a future breakup is not at the forefront of their mind. However, the growing use of fertility treatments, such as IVF, raises the issue of what should happen to embryos created by a couple if they later separate.
In this episode of The Daily from The New York Times, reporter Caroline Kitchener examines the breakup of Erin Millender and Adam Rubin, and the court case between them. The New York couple underwent IVF while they were married, including an unsuccessful embryo transfer. Millender and Rubin then separated, causing a dispute about the use of the remaining embryos.
To me, it seems that episode attempts to present a balanced perspective on their dispute. However, as only Millender is interviewed for the podcast (Rubin declined), it often falls short in this respect.
The episode begins with a description of how Millender's parents were separated when she was a young child and how she had always wanted a 'traditional family'. She speaks about her dating life and how she was focused on her career in her 20s and early 30s. However, 'when I started to get to be about 37, 38, then you really start doing the math,' says Millender, referring to concerns about the 'biological realities' of her desire to have a child.
Millender's situation resonates with me. As a woman in my 30s, some of my friendship group have young families, while others are more focused on their career or are still single. Those in the latter groups are beginning to think about what this means for their fertility, now and in the future.
The episode goes on to describe how Millender and Rubin met in 2018 and to set the scene of their relationship. Only 15 minutes into this 45-minute podcast do we get to the main topic of the episode. We hear that Millender received a diagnosis of infertility and how the couple began their journey with IVF. Unfortunately, this proved more complicated than they had hoped, with only three viable embryos from a first round of IVF, and none from a second round.
In the episode, Kitchener describes the failed embryo transfer and says that this is where the couple's perspectives seem to diverge. Reportedly, Millander struggled, bothered by her perception that her husband was less affected by the failed transfer. She told him that she no longer wanted him to attend their IVF appointments.
Kitchener reads directly from Rubin's own words: 'When I conveyed how painful it was to be excluded, she responded, you are not a priority.' He subsequently contacted the fertility clinic and withdrew his consent for the use of their two remaining embryos.
In the UK, there is a legal framework for what would happen in this scenario: both parents are able to withdraw their consent for the use of their embryos at any time. This would trigger a 12-month cooling-off period during which the embryos will continue to be stored by the fertility clinic – but cannot be used (see BioNews 1106).
In the USA, the law is not so well defined. 'Well, this area of law is the Wild West. I mean, two-thirds of states have no precedent on this issue of who would get the embryos, in the case of a couple splitting up,' Kitchener explains.
Only now does the podcast get into the main discussion of the court case between the couple. I found the background provided about the contracts used for IVF clear and helpful for understanding the context of the case. I was also interested to hear about the arguments that Millender and Rubin each brought before the court, though I was surprised that these were framed mainly around the 'right to biological parenthood.' Personally, I would have preferred to learn more about this part of the story and to hear some discussion from individuals external to the case.
Overall, I thought this episode was an interesting introduction to the legal grey area which was highlighted by the case. However, in my opinion, the episode could have focused less on Millender's dating life and their relationship, leaving room for a more nuanced discussion of Rubin's withdrawal of consent and the legal case that followed.
I also found the discussion of the dispute between Millender and Rubin one-sided at times, although I appreciate that there was an attempt to include both perspectives. Ultimately, the episode piqued my interest but left me wanting to look elsewhere to learn more about the case and the legal framework around what happens to embryos when a couple separates.


