PET PET
  • My Account
  • Subscribe
Become a Friend Donate
  • About Us
    • People
    • Press Office
    • Our History
  • Get Involved
    • Become a Friend of PET
    • Volunteer
    • Campaigns
    • Writing Scheme
    • Partnership and Sponsorship
    • Advertise with Us
  • Donate
    • Become a Friend of PET
  • BioNews
    • News
    • Comment
    • Reviews
    • Elsewhere
    • Topics
    • Glossary
    • Newsletters
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Previous Events
  • Engagement
    • Policy and Projects
      • Resources
    • Education
  • Jobs & Opportunities
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
    • People
    • Press Office
    • Our History
  • Get Involved
    • Become a Friend of PET
    • Volunteer
    • Campaigns
    • Writing Scheme
    • Partnership and Sponsorship
    • Advertise with Us
  • Donate
    • Become a Friend of PET
  • BioNews
    • News
    • Comment
    • Reviews
    • Elsewhere
    • Topics
    • Glossary
    • Newsletters
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Previous Events
  • Engagement
    • Policy and Projects
      • Resources
    • Education
  • Jobs & Opportunities
  • Contact Us
  • My Account
  • Subscribe
  • Privacy Statement
  • Advertising Policy
  • Thanks and Acknowledgements
PETBioNewsCommentSurrogacy in Ireland: A missed opportunity

BioNews

Surrogacy in Ireland: A missed opportunity

Published 6 October 2014 posted in Comment and appears in BioNews 774

Author

Fiona Duffy

Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis

Why does the Children and Family Relationships Bill 2014, published in Ireland on 25 September 2014, contain no provision for surrogacy?...

Why does the Children and Family Relationships Bill 2014, published in Ireland on 25 September 2014, contain no provision for surrogacy?

The Minister For Justice and Equality, Frances Fitzgerald, in announcing the publication of the Bill on 25 September 2014, sought to justify the exclusion of any provision for surrogacy on the basis that the Irish Supreme Court decision in the case of M.R. & Ors. V An tArd Chláraitheoir & Ors is shortly to be delivered. She also stated that more policy work and consultation is required on critical issues, such as how the law deals with commercial surrogacy and the rights of children born through surrogacy.

The M.R case, which has already been commented on in BioNews 696, concerns an application by the genetic mother of twins, born in Ireland through a surrogacy arrangement, to be registered as their mother on the children's birth certificates.

The decision of Mr Justice Abbott, delivered in the High Court on the 5 March 2013, redefined maternity. He held that the genetic mother, and not the birth mother, was the mother, and that the person with the genetic/blood link was entitled to be registered as the parent on the birth certificate. This decision means that, in the eyes of the law, all children conceived using donor gametes are the children of the donor, and in the absence of legislation this has serious ramifications for the parents of all donor-conceived children and for the meaning of motherhood. The State appealed the decision to the Supreme Court and a stay was put on this order pending judgment, which is due shortly.

On 30 January 2014, during the course of the appeal, the Irish Government announced the publication of a draft version of the Bill. Of particular importance were the provisions relating to surrogacy. Minister Shatter, the then Minister for Justice and Equality, explained that the proposed legislation would provide legal clarity on the parentage of children born through assisted human reproduction and surrogacy. A consultation process was commenced with strict instructions to report back to the Minister by Easter. The Joint Oireachtas Committee sought written submissions from interested parties, held public hearings in April and reported, as charged, in May 2014.

The report noted that the proposed legislation was strongly welcomed by most stakeholders. The Committee concluded amongst other things that no sanction should be imposed for a breach of the bill's provisions, that the definition of surrogacy should include traditional surrogacy, that time limits be extended, that posthumous conception be permitted in limited circumstances and that the draft be amended so as to include provision to protect the child's right to have access to his or her genetic identity. In other words: a positive response. Certainly there was no evidence of insurmountable obstacles, which would or could suggest any need to exclude surrogacy provisions from any proposed legislation. Indeed, the absence of such provision has taken all involved in the area by surprise.

So what has happened? Why did the Government publish the draft Bill in the first place when the Supreme Court was dealing with the Appeal and why, just before delivery of its judgment, has the Government published another version omitting all provision in relation to surrogacy?

Even though the same parties are in Government, there has been a change of personnel in the Department of Justice and Equality. Alan Shatter, the Minister and driving force behind the introduction of legislation has gone.

The version of the Bill published by Minister Shatter's department in February 2014 was prepared in consultation with the then Minister for Children, Frances Fitzgerald, who is the incumbent in the Department of Justice and Equality and as such responsible for the publication of the Bill in its current format. Both were approved by the Government.

How can one explain why Minister Fitzgerald, who was consulted in relation to the drafting of the proposed legislation in January, would now publish a draft Bill containing absolutely no provisions relating to surrogacy? Equally one must ask why the Government has approved the Bill in its current format, totally excluding any legislative or regulatory provisions relating to surrogacy.

One can only assume that this is a politically motivated decision and perhaps another example of the reluctance on the part of the Legislature to make hard decisions and define policy in this area. In my view, it is a lost opportunity.

Related Articles

Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
Comment
9 March 2015 • 2 minutes read

Legislating for assisted conception in Ireland

by Fiona Duffy

According to a recent press release from the Department of Health, the Irish Government is finally going to legislate for 'Assisted Human Reproduction and associated research'...

Image by Alan Handyside via the Wellcome Collection. Depicts a human egg soon after fertilisation, with the two parental pronuclei clearly visible.
CC0 1.0
Image by Alan Handyside via the Wellcome Collection. Depicts a human egg soon after fertilisation, with the two parental pronuclei clearly visible.
News
27 February 2015 • 3 minutes read

Ireland makes moves to ban commercial surrogacy

by Seán Byrne

The Irish Minister for Health, Leo Varadkar, has announced there will be new draft legislation to regulate surrogacy in Ireland — five months after surrogacy provisions proposed in January last year were dropped from a Bill currently before the Oireachtas...

Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
News
29 September 2014 • 3 minutes read

Irish Government drops surrogacy from family law reform

by Dr Antony Starza-Allen

The Irish Government has removed provisions on surrogacy from draft legislation reforming family law in the country, while including proposals to prohibit anonymous sperm and egg donation....

Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
Comment
10 February 2014 • 3 minutes read

General Scheme of a Children and Family Relationships Bill

by Fiona Duffy

Despite the lack of legislation and a regulatory framework in assisted conception, fertility treatment has been widely available in Ireland for many years. But in the absence of legislation, fertility clinics will not provide surrogacy services and many Irish couples requiring the use of a surrogate have, as a result, gone abroad...

Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
News
3 February 2014 • 3 minutes read

Ireland publishes draft surrogacy legislation

by Dr Antony Starza-Allen

The Irish Government has agreed to put forward proposals for a wide-ranging bill that features provisions on surrogacy and parenthood for consultation...

Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
News
6 December 2013 • 1 minute read

Woman sues Irish Government over surrogacy maternity benefits

by Dr Antony Starza-Allen

A woman in Ireland whose child was born through surrogacy is challenging the Government's refusal to pay her maternity leave, alleging that it amounts to unlawful discrimination, reports the Irish Times...

Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
News
7 June 2013 • 2 minutes read

Irish Government to appeal landmark surrogacy ruling

by Dr Jamie Heather

The Irish Government is to appeal a recent court ruling that allowed the genetic mother of twins born to a surrogate to be listed as their legal mother on their birth certificates...

Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
News
7 March 2013 • 3 minutes read

Ireland: Genetic mother wins surrogacy case

by Ruth Retassie

The Irish High Court has ruled in a landmark case that a woman who is the genetic mother of twins born through a surrogate can be recognised as the legal mother of the children....

Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
Image by Dr Christina Weis. © Christina Weis
News
25 January 2013 • 2 minutes read

Ireland: Can surrogate mother be removed from birth certificate?

by Nina Chohan

An Irish couple has brought a legal challenge against the State for refusing to remove the surrogate mother from their children's birth certificates and to register the genetic mother as a legal parent...

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

« Mitochondrial donation as a clinical option: A response to Ted Morrow

Data-Label The UK's Leading Supplier Of Medical Labels & Asset Labels

RetiringDentist.co.uk The UK's Leading M&A Company.

Find out how you can advertise here
easyfundraising
amazon

This month in BioNews

  • Popular
  • Recent
8 August 2022 • 2 minutes read

FILM: 200 Years of Mendel – From Peas to Personalised Medicine

1 August 2022 • 4 minutes read

Women's Health Strategy plans reflect rising needs of same-sex female couples

25 July 2022 • 4 minutes read

Was the Women's Health Strategy worth the wait?

25 July 2022 • 4 minutes read

Why the UK should extend the 14-day rule to 28 days

25 July 2022 • 5 minutes read

200 Years of Mendel: From Peas to Personalised Medicine

8 August 2022 • 4 minutes read

Citizenship and same-sex parents – about time, Sweden!

8 August 2022 • 2 minutes read

FILM: 200 Years of Mendel – From Peas to Personalised Medicine

1 August 2022 • 4 minutes read

Women's Health Strategy plans reflect rising needs of same-sex female couples

25 July 2022 • 4 minutes read

Was the Women's Health Strategy worth the wait?

25 July 2022 • 4 minutes read

Why the UK should extend the 14-day rule to 28 days

Subscribe to BioNews and other PET updates for free.

Subscribe
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • RSS
Wellcome
Website redevelopment supported by Wellcome.

Website by Impact Media Impact Media

  • Privacy Statement
  • Advertising Policy
  • Thanks and Acknowledgements

© 1992 - 2022 Progress Educational Trust. All rights reserved.

Limited company registered in England and Wales no 07405980 • Registered charity no 1139856

Subscribe to BioNews and other PET updates for free.

Subscribe
PET PET

PET is an independent charity that improves choices for people affected by infertility and genetic conditions.

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • RSS
Wellcome
Website redevelopment supported by Wellcome.

Navigation

  • About Us
  • Get Involved
  • Donate
  • BioNews
  • Events
  • Engagement
  • Jobs & Opportunities
  • Contact Us

BioNews

  • News
  • Comment
  • Reviews
  • Elsewhere
  • Topics
  • Glossary
  • Newsletters

Other

  • My Account
  • Subscribe

Website by Impact Media Impact Media

  • Privacy Statement
  • Advertising Policy
  • Thanks and Acknowledgements

© 1992 - 2022 Progress Educational Trust. All rights reserved.

Limited company registered in England and Wales no 07405980 • Registered charity no 1139856